Frameworks

Does Windows 8 Have Staying Power?

Microsoft has had a number of game-changing (for both better and worse) OSes over its long history. In which category will Windows 8 fit?

Microsoft has had a number of game-changing (for both better and worse) OSes over its long history. A few examples of each:

  • Windows 95, when desktop OSes finally went mainstream
  • Windows XP, an OS so good that it refuses, even today, to go gently into that good night
  • Windows 7, with the kind of features, stability and security out of the box that made it an instant global hit

Of course, Redmond has also suffered its share of horrific OSes:

  • Windows Millennium Edition (ME), Microsoft's version of the Hindenburg and Titanic all rolled up into one buggy, insecure package
  • Windows Vista, which wouldn't run almost anything upon release and got the leper treatment from users and businesses alike

And now comes Windows 8, led by two new Surface tablets that will run different versions of the OS, along with Windows Phone 8. The question for Microsoft: Will Windows 8 fit into the first or second category on this list?

Judging from the very early reports coming in, I'm feeling good about the prospects of Windows 8. The Surface announcement was met with surprise and oohs and aahs in the industry, rather than yawns.

How Microsoft pulls off this strategy is another matter entirely, of course. But it seems to this nerd that Microsoft has a chance here. Windows 8 is truly a different -- and better -- breed than the iOS/Android look and feel, and the Surface adds built-ins, like a kickstand and cover/keyboard, that the other guys don't.

What all that means is I feel confident you can start learning about and developing Windows 8 apps, and not fear that your investment will be outdated in a year or four.

About the Author

Keith Ward is the editor in chief of Visual Studio Magazine.

comments powered by Disqus

Reader Comments:

Tue, Aug 14, 2012 Mister C#

The philosophy behind Windows, as stated by Gates, was that the user would be presented a standard interface in all applications so that said user would immediately have a familiarity, to some degree, with any application they ran. For many years, you could count on the File Edit...Help on virtually any menu bar. And who broke the paradigm? Microsoft themselves when they introduced the ridiculous Ribbon Bar. IMHO, with Desktop Metro/Windows 8, they go from the ridiculous to the more so.

Tue, Aug 14, 2012 Bob Delaney Mississauga, Ontario

I have not yet run a beta copy, but I am going to give Windows 8 and the Surface computer a try. In my years as a Microsoft MVP, I found that the RTM product was neither the worst that the naysayers said, nor the magic that the commercials touted, but usually closer to the magic than the naysayers.

Tue, Aug 14, 2012 Bob St. Louis

Win 8 will be DOA... Metro is a complete desktop disaster. What Kool-Aid have you been drinking? Are you deaf?

Tue, Aug 14, 2012 Long Time Windows Developer

I installed Windows 8 multiple times to be fair, and I still can't believe this is what is going to be released for the desktop. It's OK for checking facebook, twitter, and weather but beyond that it's a distraction. How hard would it have been to give the user a choice to boot win7 or win8 metro. For those who want to get work done, like myself, it's just plain annoying. As a developer, I've decided to dust off the java books, because I think there is more future in android then Redmond now given this direction and the rapid deprecation of windows technologies lately. HTML apps are the not the answer to everything.

Tue, Aug 14, 2012 A Developer

First, we get the concept of the Cloud shoved down our throats. Then Apple decides the PC Era is a thing of the past and they transform their desktop OS into an amateur clone of their mobile OS. And who is that sniffing at Apple's behind and imitating the "innovations"? Microsoft, of course! My company has already issued a "pass" on Windows 8. The question asked around here is how can Microsoft backpedal to a useable Enterprise OS with Windows 9? Some people still use computers for productive efforts. Not everyone needs an OS that let's them know what color underwear their friend just bought or what song some perfect stranger who lives in New Jersey with his mother is listening to. When did the brains leave Redmond?

Tue, Aug 14, 2012 Tom Pittsburgh

After using Win 8 RP for quite some time now I can say without reservation the answer to the title is a resounding "NO". It is okay, don't get me wrong, but just as Windows Vista introduced true security to Windows and was scorned until fixed by Windows 7; Windows 8 will be superceded in the near future by something that is similar to Windows 8, but far more useable to everyone. Is Windows 8 better than Windows 7? Maybe. Is it useable? Marginally, but not as much as Windows 7. Should you switch to Windows 8? Only for very specific reasons that need well articulated. It will be resisted and generally hated by any users forced to upgrade - a useless aggrivation to put people through without good reason.

Tue, Aug 14, 2012 Deepak

The mouse/keyboard interface on Metro is truly horrible. I'd vote for the 2nd category.

Add Your Comments Now:

Your Name:(optional)
Your Email:(optional)
Your Location:(optional)
Comment:
Please type the letters/numbers you see above