VS Toolbox: Red Gate Software SQL Source Control -- Visual Studio Magazine

Product Reviews

Manage Database Design with Red Gate SQL Source Control

Red Gate SQL Source Control is a useful tool for SQL Server developers using TFS or Subversion, but falls short in managing database design changes.

By Peter Vogel
12/01/2010

Red Gate Software Ltd. has always provided tools for managing SQL Server databases. The company's latest offering is SQL Source Control, which, to quote Red Gate's marketing, promises to "bring all of the benefits of source control to your database." That's not quite true, but it's close enough.

SQL Source Control isn't a standalone tool -- it's actually the intersection between the Red Gate SQL Compare tool and a source-control package, either Team Foundation Server (TFS) or Subversion (SVN). SQL Compare, when given two databases, produces a script that converts one database into a copy of the other. What SQL Source Control brings to the party is a simplified way to generate that delta list and commit it to your source-control system. In many ways, this is how a sophisticated source-control package works -- it stores the changes from one version to another.

With your database changes under source control, you can replace a database with one of the versions stored in source control. You can also view all the history of changes made to the database, when they were made and who they were made by. Using an SVN bug or TFS work item, you can also associate a database change with a bug-tracking system -- for example, TFS or Fogbugz.

ToolTracker: Free or Almost-Free Data-Modeling Tools

Is ERwin Data Modeler overkill for your needs? Consider these low-cost or no-cost alternatives.

ERwin Community Edition will reverse engineer and generate a database from a model. But it's limited to 25 objects, which cripples it for real apps. It will compare two databases but won't synchronize them. tinyurl.com/28ocxmh
Oracle SQL Developer Data Modeler surprisingly supports SQL Server natively, rather than through ODBC. It uses the Barker and Bachman notations. tinyurl.com/2dpeh5t
DBDesigner-Fork originally was built for MySQL, but the current version actually supports SQL Server. tinyurl.com/baca9x
wwwsqldesigner lets you design databases in your browser and export a script to implement your design -- but there's no reverse engineering. tinyurl.com/5pse87
Enterprise Architect costs just $100. It uses UML for modeling notation and includes database generation and reverse engineering. tinyurl.com/bador

-- P.V.

However, to fully embrace the "database changes as source control" paradigm, I'd expect to be able to do more -- to create forks in my database design, for instance. You don't get that, at least not directly. Also, SQL Source Control doesn't so much roll your database design forward or backward as replace the current version with your selected version. That's too bad, but for the price you pay (about $700 for SQL Compare plus SQL Source Control) you'll save the equivalent time on your next version release.

[Click on image for larger view.]

Apply changes from source control to your database structure and review the history of those changes from SQL Server Management Studio.

You must install SQL Source Control on a computer with SQL Server Management Studio (SSMS) or SSMS Express 2008.

SQL Source Control

Red Gate Software Ltd.
Web: red-gate.com
Phone: 866-997-0397
Price: $295
Quick Facts: Integrates other Red Gate products into one of two popular source-control tools
Pros: Integrates with SQL Server Management Studio to provide simple source control for database design changes
Cons: Not a complete source-control management tool; only directly supports replacing versions of a database with a version from your source-control system

About the Author

Peter Vogel is a system architect and principal in PH&V Information Services. PH&V provides full-stack consulting from UX design through object modeling to database design. Peter tweets about his VSM columns with the hashtag #vogelarticles. His blog posts on user experience design can be found at http://blog.learningtree.com/tag/ui/.

Printable Format

comments powered by Disqus

Featured

Hands On: New VS Code Insiders Build Creates Web Page from Image in Seconds

New Vision support with GitHub Copilot in the latest Visual Studio Code Insiders build takes a user-supplied mockup image and creates a web page from it in seconds, handling all the HTML and CSS.
Naive Bayes Regression Using C#

Dr. James McCaffrey from Microsoft Research presents a complete end-to-end demonstration of the naive Bayes regression technique, where the goal is to predict a single numeric value. Compared to other machine learning regression techniques, naive Bayes regression is usually less accurate, but is simple, easy to implement and customize, works on both large and small datasets, is highly interpretable, and doesn't require tuning any hyperparameters.
VS Code Copilot Previews New GPT-4o AI Code Completion Model

The 4o upgrade includes additional training on more than 275,000 high-quality public repositories in over 30 popular programming languages, said Microsoft-owned GitHub, which created the original "AI pair programmer" years ago.
Microsoft's Rust Embrace Continues with Azure SDK Beta

"Rust's strong type system and ownership model help prevent common programming errors such as null pointer dereferencing and buffer overflows, leading to more secure and stable code."
Xcode IDE from Microsoft Archrival Apple Gets Copilot AI

Just after expanding the reach of its Copilot AI coding assistant to the open-source Eclipse IDE, Microsoft showcased how it's going even further, providing details about a preview version for the Xcode IDE from archrival Apple.