Desmond File

Blog archive

Digital Darwinism

One of the remarkable things about Microsoft has been its willingness to fail. By that, I don't mean that the company welcomes or admits defeat to competitors. One need only glance at efforts like Microsoft Network (MSN) or products like Microsoft Money and the Zune media player to realize that Redmond will invest what it takes, as long as it takes, to challenge incumbent technologies.

What I mean is that Microsoft is happy to pit competing, homegrown technologies against each other. It's the sort of tough-minded digital Darwinism that has helped make Microsoft a technology powerhouse, and should help ensure that it remains dominant for years to come. Consider the dueling 32-bit operating systems of Windows NT and Windows 95, which ultimately merged into the Windows XP OS. Or more recently, look at the multiple data access methods Microsoft has developed to support the growing demand for efficient, data-driven programming.

As Jeffrey Schwartz reports in his Data Driver blog, Microsoft is picking a winner between the popular LINQ to SQL technology, introduced with Visual Studio 2008 and .NET Framework 3.5, and the recently released ADO .NET Entity Framework. And if Jeffrey's report is any indication, some developers aren't terribly happy about it.

And that can be a problem. By promoting multiple, overlapping technologies, Microsoft often invites confusion and even disruption in the dev market.

I asked Anders Hejlsberg, technical fellow in the Developer Division at Microsoft and a driving force behind the creation of LINQ, for his thoughts on Microsoft's change of direction. He said this sort of competition between technologies is "unavoidable" in part because of Microsoft's sheer size.

"The bigger a company gets, the more there is to keep track of and the more overlap that you see because we are doing more things," Hejlsberg said. "Now the LINQ to SQL project was an interesting project because it was built by the C# team, but it is clearly in the data domain. We built it because we needed something real to validate LINQ, and we strongly felt that LINQ would be nothing without a strong O-R mapper to support it."

Once the C# team's work on LINQ to SQL was done, Hejlsberg said, the technology was handed over to the ADO.NET group.

Obviously Microsoft is making its choices, but that doesn't mean developers currently using LINQ to SQL have to drop everything and work with Entity Framework. Hejlsberg emphasized that LINQ to SQL will continue to be supported.

"LINQ to SQL is not dead. I can assure you, it is not dead. Nothing ever goes away. We have never done that and we never will," he said.

What do you think of Microsoft's decision to shift focus away from LINQ to SQL? Has your dev shop been burned Microsoft's internal competition in the past? E-mail me at [email protected].

Posted by Michael Desmond on 12/11/2008 at 1:15 PM

comments powered by Disqus


  • Microsoft's Tools to Fight Solorigate Attack Are Now Open Source

    Microsoft open sourced homegrown tools it used to check its systems for code related to the recent massive breach of supply chains that the company has named Solorigate.

  • Microsoft's Lander on Blazor Desktop: 'I Don't See a Grand Unified App Model in the Future'

    For all of the talk of unifying the disparate ecosystem of Microsoft-centric developer tooling -- using one framework for apps of all types on all platforms -- Blazor Desktop is not the answer. There isn't one.

  • Firm Automates Legacy Web Forms-to-ASP.NET Core Conversions

    Migration technology uses the Angular web framework and Progress Kendo UI user interface elements to convert ASP.NET Web Forms client code to HTML and CSS, with application business logic converted automatically to ASP.NET Core.

  • New TypeScript 4.2 Tweaks Include Project Explainer

    Microsoft shipped TypeScript 4.2 -- the regular quarterly update to the open source programming language that improves JavaScript with static types -- with a host of tweaks including a way to explain why files are included in a project.

Upcoming Events