Federal Appeals Court Upholds Ban on Microsoft Word Sales -- Visual Studio Magazine

Federal Appeals Court Upholds Ban on Microsoft Word Sales

By Becky Nagel
12/22/2009

Microsoft must stop selling its Microsoft Word software starting Jan. 11 if it can't remove patent-infringing technology by that time, according to a federal appeals court ruling released today.

The appeals court also upheld an approximate $290 million judgment against Redmond, plus interest and court costs.

The ruling stems from a lower-court case earlier this year in which a jury found Microsoft guilty of "willfully" infringing on a custom XML-related patent owned by Toronto-based i4i (United States Patent No. 5,787,449). The original judgment ordered Microsoft to stop selling Word products "that have the capability of opening a .XML, .DOCX, or .DOCM file ('an XML file') containing custom XML."

According to a statement released by Microsoft Director of Public Affairs Kevin Kutz, Microsoft has "been preparing for this possibility since the District Court issued its injuction...and have put the wheels in place to remove this little-used feature from [Microsoft Word 2007 and Microsoft Office 2007]."

"Therefore, we expect to have copies...with this feature removed available for U.S. sale and distribution by the injunction date."

"In addition," he continued, "the beta versions of Microsoft Word 2010...do not contain the technology covered by the injunction."

Kutz also stated that while the company is preparing to comply with the injunction, it is also considering an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

i4i did not release a statement regarding the ruling by press time.

About the Author

Becky Nagel serves as vice president of AI for 1105 Media specializing in developing media, events and training for companies around AI and generative AI technology. She also regularly writes and reports on AI news, and is the founding editor of PureAI.com. She's the author of "ChatGPT Prompt 101 Guide for Business Users" and other popular AI resources with a real-world business perspective. She regularly speaks, writes and develops content around AI, generative AI and other business tech. Find her on X/Twitter @beckynagel.

Printable Format

comments powered by Disqus

Featured

In .NET 9 Debut, Microsoft Focuses on .NET Aspire, AI

Microsoft shipped .NET 9 today with the dev team highlighting .NET Aspire and AI in a keynote and follow-on sessions of the livestreamed launch event.
Microsoft Intros 'Guided Chat Experience' for GitHub Copilot in Visual Studio

Microsoft introduced a new guided chat experience within GitHub Copilot, aiming to make developer interactions with AI more natural and effective.
Microsoft's Open-Source Semantic Kernel AI Toolkit Extends to AWS Cloud

Microsoft announced its open-source Semantic Kernel toolkit for integrating advanced AI models into applications is now available on the Amazon Bedrock managed service.
Microsoft Previews Copilot AI in SQL Server Management Studio

In announcing SSMS 21 Preview 1 this week, Microsoft revealed Copilot AI for the tool is also being previewed, privately.
DBSCAN Clustering and Anomaly Detection Using C#

Dr. James McCaffrey from Microsoft Research presents a complete end-to-end demonstration of data clustering and anomaly detection using the DBSCAN (Density Based Spatial Clustering of Applications with Noise) algorithm. Compared to other anomaly detection systems based on data clustering, DBSCAN can find significantly different types of anomalies.