.NET Tips and Tricks

Blog archive

Designing with the Dependency Inversion Principle

The Dependency Inversion Principle says "the interface belongs to the client." As I've said elsewhere, adopting this principle means a reversing of the way applications used to be built: Design the database, build the objects to maintain the tables, wrap a UI around those objects and then bring the users in for training because they'd never figure the application out on their own.

The Dependency Inversion Principle says: Build the UIs that your users will understand (the interface belongs to them), design the objects that will make those UIs easy to build, build those classes, design the objects that make those classes easy to build and carry on until code-first Entity Framework generates the database you need.

You know this, already: the Dependency Inversion Principle is what drives the essential difference between ADO.NET and Entity Framework. With ADO.NET, it was your responsibility to create a connection (because you need a connection to the database), create a correctly configured command object (because you have to issue commands), call the appropriate execute method (because different SQL commands work differently) and then manage fetching rows and turning them into objects (because ... well, you get the picture). In other words, ADO.NET's API was driven by how the ADO.NET objects worked -- the reverse of the Dependency Inversion Principle.

On the other hand, essentially what Entity Framework says is, "Tell me what objects you want and I'll get them for you." Entity Framework provides the API that the application wants: An object-oriented way of retrieving, adding, updating and deleting data.

There are real cost-savings associated with the Dependency Inversion Principle. Because the principle requires that objects deliver the functionality that the client wants, interfaces tend to be more stable. Following the principle, APIs only change because the client program wants to do something differently (which, when you think about it, is the only reason we should be changing our code). You're welcome to upgrade how your objects work, of course ... but you're not allowed to change the API.

Of course, this level of abstraction isn't free: Entity Framework doesn't have the performance that pure ADO.NET has, even for the scenarios it targets: online, transactional applications. However, it does improve the productivity of developers who, let's face it (and given the current cost of hardware), are the most expensive part of an application -- just ask my client. And, when you do need "bare metal" levels of performance, there's always Dapper.

And, quite frankly, if you wanted the fastest performance, you'd be writing your code in assembler and running it on MS-DOS. Let's not be silly about performance.

Posted by Peter Vogel on 02/27/2019


comments powered by Disqus

Featured

  • Microsoft Revamps Fledgling AutoGen Framework for Agentic AI

    Only at v0.4, Microsoft's AutoGen framework for agentic AI -- the hottest new trend in AI development -- has already undergone a complete revamp, going to an asynchronous, event-driven architecture.

  • IDE Irony: Coding Errors Cause 'Critical' Vulnerability in Visual Studio

    In a larger-than-normal Patch Tuesday, Microsoft warned of a "critical" vulnerability in Visual Studio that should be fixed immediately if automatic patching isn't enabled, ironically caused by coding errors.

  • Building Blazor Applications

    A trio of Blazor experts will conduct a full-day workshop for devs to learn everything about the tech a a March developer conference in Las Vegas keynoted by Microsoft execs and featuring many Microsoft devs.

  • Gradient Boosting Regression Using C#

    Dr. James McCaffrey from Microsoft Research presents a complete end-to-end demonstration of the gradient boosting regression technique, where the goal is to predict a single numeric value. Compared to existing library implementations of gradient boosting regression, a from-scratch implementation allows much easier customization and integration with other .NET systems.

  • Microsoft Execs to Tackle AI and Cloud in Dev Conference Keynotes

    AI unsurprisingly is all over keynotes that Microsoft execs will helm to kick off the Visual Studio Live! developer conference in Las Vegas, March 10-14, which the company described as "a must-attend event."

Subscribe on YouTube