Weak Pointers and Circular References in C++ 11: Listing 4

A generic solution to circular references.

// circular_ptr.h

#include <memory>

using namespace std;

template <typename T>
class circular_ptr;

// this header only offers the prototype of this template function.
// Implementors of a concrete types T should provide specific versions, and make this
// function friend to T (see class person in Listing 5).
template <typename T>
circular_ptr<T> *get_circular_ptr(const shared_ptr<T>&);

template <typename T>
class circular_ptr {
  circular_ptr() : strong_{nullptr}, weak_{} {}

  // copy constructor
  circular_ptr(shared_ptr<T> &t) : strong_{nullptr}, weak_{} {

  // copy assignment operator
  circular_ptr& operator=(shared_ptr<T> &t) {
    return set(t);

  shared_ptr<T> get() const {
    if (strong_!=nullptr)
      return strong_;
      return weak_.lock();

  // whether circular_ptr uses a weak link to refer to a T instance.
  bool is_weak() {
    return !(weak_.expired());

  // releases its link, whichever it is (strong or weak).
  bool reset() {
    // looks for a weak link that directly or not points to the this circular_ptr
    circular_ptr *weak_one = find_weak_link_reaching_this();

    // if found, means that there was a circular reference. That circular reference is
    // being broken in this reset. Consequently, the weak ptr must become strong.
    if (weak_one) {
        weak_one->strong_ = weak_one->weak_.lock();


    return (weak_one);

  bool operator==(const circular_ptr &other) const {
    return get()==other.get();

  bool operator!=(const circular_ptr &other) const {
    return !(*this==other);
  // this function is O(n) in non-deterministic cases. A deterministic circularity
  // scenario may override this function to get constant order of complexity.
  virtual bool is_this_reachable_from(const shared_ptr<T> &start) const {
    shared_ptr<T> current = start, currents_next;

    // it basically performs a walkthrough from start argument to see whether it reaches
    // this instance or null. If the former, returns true. False otherwise.
    if (current!=nullptr) {
        do {
            currents_next = get_circular_ptr(current)->get();
            if ((currents_next!=nullptr)&&(this==get_circular_ptr(currents_next))) {
                return true;

            current = currents_next;
        while ((current!=nullptr)&&(current!=start));

    return false;

  // same comment: if circularity is deterministic, this function could be overridden and
  // thus optimized
  virtual circular_ptr *find_weak_link_reaching_this() {
    circular_ptr *current = this, *weak_one = nullptr;
    // provided that there's no strong circular reference, either the chain ends in nullptr
    // or we reach a member that is weak
    while (current!=nullptr) {
        if (current->is_weak()) {
            weak_one = current;
            // now, it must be confirmed that *this is reachable from weak_one.
            do {
                if ((current = get_circular_ptr(current->get()))==this)
                  return weak_one;
            while (current!=weak_one);
            // provided that weak_one is reachable from current, as weak_one is weak
            // because participates in a loop.

        if (shared_ptr<T> t = current->get()) current = get_circular_ptr(t);
        else break;

    return nullptr;
  shared_ptr<T> strong_;
  weak_ptr<T> weak_;

  circular_ptr& set(shared_ptr<T> &t) {
    if (t==nullptr) {
    else {
        bool cycle_already_detected = false;

        if (get()!=nullptr) {
            cycle_already_detected = reset();

        // checking for cycle_already_detected helps avoid an extra round
        if ((cycle_already_detected)||( is_this_reachable_from(t)))
          weak_ = t;
          strong_ = t;

    return *this;

#endif /* CIRCULAR_PTR_H_ */

About the Author

Diego Dagum is a software architect and developer with more than 20 years of experience. He can be reached at [email protected]

comments powered by Disqus


  • New Visual Studio Razor Editor 'Close to Being Ready' for Blazor and Other Projects

    The experimental Razor editor for Visual Studio introduced last summer has been updated and is "close to being ready for normal daily development."

  • Microsoft Updates 'Must Have' Xamarin Community Toolkit

    The Xamarin Community Toolkit provides all kinds of effects, views and helpers to complement mobile app development with Microsoft's recently released, open source, cross-platform Xamarin.Forms 5.

  • JetBrains Unveils Plans for WinForms, WPF and More in Rider .NET IDE

    JetBrains announced plans for Windows Forms, Windows Presentation Foundation (WPF), ASP.NET and more tooling in the next release of its popular Rider IDE for .NET development.

  • Multi-Class Classification Using PyTorch: Model Accuracy

    Dr. James McCaffrey of Microsoft Research continues his four-part series on multi-class classification, designed to predict a value that can be one of three or more possible discrete values, by explaining model accuracy.

Upcoming Events