.NET Tips and Tricks

Blog archive

Reporting Exceptions Well in Visual Studio

Microsoft has some "best practice" advice to share on how to handle exceptions (a topic I've discussed elsewhere). The Microsoft article is well worth reading ... but there's one piece of advice that I disagree with (talk about hubris, eh?).

One of Microsoft's recommended practices is that you should prefer to throw a built-in Exception class rather than your own, custom Exception class. The problem I see with this is that the built-in Exception objects return, at best, the technical reason for the exception (for example, "Division by zero"). Creating your own exception object allows you to specify the business reason for the failure (for example, "Customer has no sales orders").

Personally, I think that the message with the business reason is more useful both to the user faced with the message and the developer who has to fix the problem. Instead, I recommend using a custom exception object and tucking the original Exception into your custom Exception object's InnerException property. That gives you the best of both worlds.

Posted by Peter Vogel on 04/26/2019


comments powered by Disqus

Featured

  • IDE Irony: Coding Errors Cause 'Critical' Vulnerability in Visual Studio

    In a larger-than-normal Patch Tuesday, Microsoft warned of a "critical" vulnerability in Visual Studio that should be fixed immediately if automatic patching isn't enabled, ironically caused by coding errors.

  • Building Blazor Applications

    A trio of Blazor experts will conduct a full-day workshop for devs to learn everything about the tech a a March developer conference in Las Vegas keynoted by Microsoft execs and featuring many Microsoft devs.

  • Gradient Boosting Regression Using C#

    Dr. James McCaffrey from Microsoft Research presents a complete end-to-end demonstration of the gradient boosting regression technique, where the goal is to predict a single numeric value. Compared to existing library implementations of gradient boosting regression, a from-scratch implementation allows much easier customization and integration with other .NET systems.

  • Microsoft Execs to Tackle AI and Cloud in Dev Conference Keynotes

    AI unsurprisingly is all over keynotes that Microsoft execs will helm to kick off the Visual Studio Live! developer conference in Las Vegas, March 10-14, which the company described as "a must-attend event."

  • Copilot Agentic AI Dev Environment Opens Up to All

    Microsoft removed waitlist restrictions for some of its most advanced GenAI tech, Copilot Workspace, recently made available as a technical preview.

Subscribe on YouTube