Letters from Readers

Letters From Readers: Will Windows 8 Tablets Succeed?

The October cover story on the unveiling of Windows 8 featured comments about the viability of Microsoft tablets in the market. They provoked a strong response.

The October cover story on the unveiling of Windows 8 featured comments by developer David Platt about the viability of Microsoft tablets in the market. They provoked a strong response.

I think David Platt is somewhat missing the point by wondering who will be buying Samsung Windows 8 tablets "as Christmas presents." The answer is: very few. The right question to ask is, "As enterprise customers and SMEs begin to introduce tablets to their workers -- mainly mobile workers, in the beginning -- what types of tablets will they buy?"

And I think the answer to that is: Where Microsoft is hoping to find an opportunity to gain large market share. Most companies are just now starting to experiment with tablets, and even then as "adjunct," or companion devices. And most companies have invested heavily in applications -- including line-of-business apps and use of Microsoft Office products -- that run on Windows.

I've done enough work for large organizations to know that most of their developers have zero experience creating business apps in Objective C. Android is slightly better, in that the Eclipse IDE runs on Windows, and Java skills are common, but porting enterprise apps to Android would still be an enormous task.

CTOs/CIOs will look at their options: For a per-unit cost in the same ballpark as a 3G-enabled iPad 2, or Galaxy Tab 10.1, they can get a Samsung, or (no doubt coming) a Lenovo ThinkPad tablet with close to the same form-factor, but which runs everything without having to rewrite apps, no worries about supporting new network authentication mechanisms and so on. Microsoft isn't aiming (initially) at consumers, I think it's targeting business users.

Posted online

The lure of Windows 8 machines will be the late-2012 hybrid laptop/tablet with a fold-away keyboard. You get the Desktop Windows primarily, and the Metro touch interface for free.

Posted online

Platt is right and wrong about Microsoft tools. Microsoft has good tools -- relative to everything else. But that's a lot like saying, "Best American Mobile Phone Company." The fact that one of them can say "best" is still a relative statement. From this dev's perspective, spending time at the conference and watching Microsoft dev after Microsoft dev dig out Visual Studio and then edit XAML without tooling, without a single demonstration anywhere in Visual Basic, suggests to me that "best" means "best Windows Forms tooling, and now look over here at this cool HTML5 stuff!" Doesn't come close to supporting the simple quick use cases Visual Basic 6 did. 

Posted online

Visual Studio Magazine wants to hear from you! Send us your thoughts about recent stories, technology updates or whatever's on your mind.

E-mail us at [email protected] and be sure to include your first and last name, city and state. Please note that letters may be edited for form, fit and style. They express the views of the individual authors, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the VSM editors or 1105 Media Inc.

About the Author

This story was written or compiled based on feedback from the readers of Visual Studio Magazine.

comments powered by Disqus


  • ML.NET Improves Object Detection

    Microsoft improved the object detection capabilities of its ML.NET machine learning framework for .NET developers, adding the ability to train custom models with Model Builder in Visual Studio.

  • More Improvements for VS Code's New Python Language Server

    Microsoft announced more improvements for the new Python language server for Visual Studio Code, Pylance, specializing in rich type information.

  • Death of the Dev Machine?

    Here's a takeaway from this week's Ignite 2020 event: An advanced Azure cloud portends the death of the traditional, high-powered dev machine packed with computing, memory and storage components.

  • COVID-19 Is Ignite 2020's Elephant in the Room: 'Frankly, It Sucks'

    As in all things of our new reality, there was no escaping the drastic changes in routine caused by the COVID-19 pandemic during Microsoft's big Ignite 2020 developer/IT pro conference, this week shifted to an online-only event after drawing tens of thousands of in-person attendees in years past.

  • Visual Studio 2019 v16.8 Preview Update Adds Codespaces

    To coincide with the Microsoft Ignite 2020 IT pro/developer event, the Visual Studio dev team shipped a new update, Visual Studio 2019 v16.8 Preview 3.1, with the main attraction being support for cloud-hosted Codespaces, now in a limited beta.

Upcoming Events